1: Ternate
JDT:
There has been a curse or pattern that has emerged across every single CBR installment - the 61st seeded civ in the episode 0 rankings will never finish 61st. Of course, due to the statistical variability present in any CBR since Civ and the Civ AI are such fickle things with many confounding factors, alongside the fact that the PRs are a statistical average, this is not exactly uncommon or unexpected. What is unexpected is how often the supposed bottom feeders are actually pretty good.
Since Mk2, the only time a 61st seed actually ended up behaving about as expected was Jamaica in X2, who died in 51st or 50th having done very little aside from forward settling Gran Colombia, who also weren’t great. Morocco survived into the 40s, famously creating a bizarre colonial empire off the Ashanti and having good scraps with Portugal and Mali. Haiti survived into the 30s despite not really doing much after almost sniping Caracas from Venezuela. Timor Leste needs no introduction, being arguably the greatest story this wild medium ever told. And Singapore threatened to almost do a Timor Leste, becoming arguably the best civ from their region ever (challenging only X2 Malacca) and becoming a polarizing but ruthlessly efficient powerhouse. In comparison, Ternate… lets just say didn’t tern-ate great.
Ternate started out fulfilling their low expectations in a swell manner, settling around their historical region and getting their cities fat. Then in episode 3, they were assaulted by Lanfang. What people thought could be a quick execution however, quickly turned into a nothingburger war. It was here where people realized that Ternate simply cannot die.
For some reason, Ternate were able to stack really high city defense on a bunch of their cities, most notably Sidangoli and Ternate proper. What this means is that while they were inferior statistically to Lanfang, Bunuba and later Cebu, nobody can actually pierce them. Time and time again people tried to attack them. Every time they would fail. Lanfang, Cebu, Bunuba, Caral, Chono, Japan, Ryukyu, none were able to properly break them in a decisive military conflict. Hell, they even were arguably winning against Bunuba. However, herein came the straw that broke Ternate’s back - in episode 13 they gave away Dodinga to Caral, a civ who didn’t border them and were more than happy to accept the trade, promptly getting the city placed in Bunuba hands once again
From this point onwards, it was a downward spiral. Sampalu and their Polynesian exclaves were seized by Japan and Caral. And then, the chaser happened. Cebu decided to attack them while they were battered and exhausted. At first, it was thought to potentially be a nothingburger war. However, city defense had decayed quite a bit and Cebu was statistically superior whilst being, well, Cebu. And so, Ternate would get completely eviscerated, having every city of theirs taken in one fell swoop, before ignominiously getting eliminated by a Chono expeditionary force sweeping through from Quellon.
Ternate will not be remembered in these halls. Too good to be remembered as a loser, too bad to be remembered as an actual contender. If they were remembered for anything it would be their downfall starting Cebu’s own and Lanfang’s rise, an outcome that is dubious to speculate about. But I’ll be real here - it's kind of refreshing to have the bottom rank civ actually perform pretty poorly for once. F.
No comments yet.